«

Greater Downtown - Transit

| Main |

Greater Downtown - A Tale Of Two Markets

»

Greater Downtown - Traffic Tranquilizers

Too bad you're not a car.  You have plenty of weight in the trunk, and you're full of gas.
Any discussion of pedestrianizing the downtown must consider traffic calming tactics, and implement best practices in this area. The process is incremental, and not without some controversy, inasmuch as its explicit purpose is to reduce traffic velocity and volume. Motorists, understandably but mistakenly, want to cover ground with dispatch, what with time being money and all.

It's sort of puzzling to me, because we aren't born in automobiles. Every car ride begins and ends with a walk. So the reflexive hostility that motorists and pedestrians routinely exhibit for each other is strange. When driving into downtown, the driver sees each pedestrian crossing the street as an obstacle, but as soon as he's out of his car and crossing the street, he sees other motorists as the enemy, and purposely slows his gait to further inconvenience the oncoming soccer mom in the Escalade bearing down on him.

No wonder people go to the mall. Once safely inside the climate-controlled uberstore, the gravest hazard they face is indigestion from the food court.

Traffic calming is not a new subject in Chico. In the recent redesign of East Eighth street, for example, three roundabouts were planned, specifically to calm traffic while facilitating smoother traffic flow. Were the residents along the corridor happy about this? No. Instead, they mau-maued the designers, insisting, essentially, that they don't like their traffic calm and smooth, they like it frenetic and rough. Go figure.

But other neighborhoods around Chico, confronted with thoughtless drivers speeding along residential streets, have petitioned the city for increased traffic calming measures, and where they've been implemented, they've been effective.

Usually, this means "speed bumps" (or, as they're called in Europe, "sleeping policemen"). But this is only one of many weapons in the traffic calmiing toolkit.

The Project for Public Spaces has a comprehensive catalog of traffic calming measures, summarized on the next page.

Diagonal Parking

Chico is starting to do this already, more for the purpose of increasing available parking in high-demand areas, but it also has a traffic calming benefit. According to PPS, it changes both the perception and the function of a street. Because both parked and oncoming motorists must be increasingly alert to one another, this increased awareness improves awareness of pedestrians.

Changing One-Way Streets to Two-Way

I discussed this on last Wednesday's entry, and pedestrian convenience was one of the benefits of considering changing Third, Fourth, Main, and Broadway to two-ways. And because it also increases motorist convenience, the potential for motorist frustration to result in a pedestrian injury is reduced.

Narrowing Lanes, Widening Sidewalks

This seems self-evident. The wider the roadway, the faster the motorist thinks he can safely travel. We see this every day on Broadway at First Street. Drivers that have been blissfully cruising along at 27 miles per hour on Esplanade suddenly speed up and shift from lane to lane trying to achieve some competitive advantage even though the lights are metered for the same speed they've been traveling. Another advantage of narrow strees with wider sidewalks is that pedestrians have shorter crossings, plus more space on the sidewalk for foot traffic.

Bulbs, Chokers, Neckdowns

We already have bulbs at many intersections in downtown Chico. These serve as refuges for pedestrians waiting to cross the streets. They also shorten the crossing distance, define parking bays, and provide space for amenities like trash receptable, bike racks, trees, etc.

Chicanes

This technique uses extended portions of sidewalks to give a street a "curving" aspect. Drivers instinctively slow down when the road goes from straight to curved. One way of using chicanes on a three-lane one-way street would be to extend the sidewalk from the right-hand sidewalk at the beginning of the block for about a quarter of the way, and extending the left-hand sidewalk at the end of the block for the last quarter. This encourages through traffic to stay in the center lane, and discourages left-turns, which tend to cause traffic latency, increasing congestion and emissions.

Traffic Circles and Roundabouts

9th-Park.jpgWe've been having a lively discussion of traffic circles in Chico for several years, and while some people are still stubbornly opposed to them, I think they've proven their value in selected circumstances. They are especially useful when more than two streets converge on the same point. For example, the intersection where Park Avenue, East Ninth Street, Humboldt, and Oroville Avenue all connect (shown at right) would be well served by a traffic circle that would permit a smooth flow of traffic without stopping.

Raised Medians

A new on of these was recently installed at Vallambrosa and Mangrove, to discourage traffic in and out of the new corporate shopping center there from crossing to or from the eastbound lanes. But they also serve to slow traffic, and provide pedestrian refuges between lanes.

Tight Corner Curbs

The sharper the turn, the slower the driver. This technique also provides pedestrians with greater visibility of oncoming traffic, and gives motorists better visibility of pedestrians. It also creates additional sidewalk space for pedestrians, and typically shortens crossings, as well.

Diverters

This is a technique to force traffic to follow specific patterns, essentially dedicating some roadways to vehicles, freeing up other corridors for pedestrian and bicycle traffic.

Speed Bumps

These would be very useful to slow down traffic approaching downtown from either direction of Second Street, which, combined with diverters, could encourage more motorists to use Third and Fourth as their through streets, rather than trying to cross the downtown on Second. These would also be useful on Broadway and Main to reduce through traffic and the "raceway effect".

Of course, these techniques can only be useful as part of an overall traffic management strategy for the city center. Applying them like band-aids to problem spots only tends to rrelocate the problems elsewhere. Access and traffic management have always been an important part of the ongoing discussion about downtown, and I hope that some of these mechanisms can be adapted to downtown Chico's unique requirements.

Comments

Other benifits to diagonal parking

All doors open in a safty zone.. between cars

It creates a wider buffer between the sidewalk and traffic. This gives mother the chance to catchup to a child when they break free. thats not a perception. its survival.

The sidewalk bulbs are now the length of the car. not the width

More street parking stimulates a known retail fact... Americans shop convience 1st.. value 2nd

Cars come standard with backup lights. as soon as you put it in reverse it alerts drivers looking for a space. A very rational way to comunicate your intentions. Drivers looking for a space provide the gap in traffic needed to backout.

The majority of drivers hate and avoid parallel parking. to the point of finding other places to go.

puts more parking on the street at a fraction of the cost of a parking garage

If we employed the benifits of diagonal on Broadway, Main and other streets. You would be on the side of a desirable place to be. for both the public and attracting good/great business.

If we use up all the resouces to build bulk parking first it will take beyond our years to create a desirable place.

Mike

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)