First, let me share with you Keith Olbermann's Special Comment on Proposition 8 from last night:
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you....
"I was reading last night of the aspiration of the old Persian poet, Omar Khayyam. It appealed to me as the highest that I can vision. I wish it was in my heart, and I wish it was in the hearts of all.
So I be written in the Book of Love,
I do not care about that Book above.
Erase my name or write it as you will,
So I be written in the Book of Love."
Personally, I have never believed in marriage. Why would I believe in an institution we enter into, planning for it's end, with a 50% chance of survival - and whom not all people in our society can participate in? I joked in the days leading up to the election about how when this proposition did not pass, I would have to find another reason for not wanting to ever get married. But in the back of my head I began to become comfortable with the idea of marriage, to support it, to maybe even desire it. And then, on November 4th my desire was shattered, my comfort was stripped away from me with BARELY even half of voting Californians deciding that my state was going to deny a basic human right to people simply because they were different. My support grew exponentially.
Keith refers to interracial marriages being denied, or even black marriages being denied, back in the darkest days of our history. We refer to those times with disgust and shame - I wonder how our grandchildren will look back and describe November 4th!
Our history is littered with the denials of basic human rights - and people fighting to achieve them. Most notably for me is the woman's suffrage movement, and the ratification of the 19th Amendment to include women in the right to vote - an amendment I thank God for every election day. For it's only been 88 years now that women have been able to vote - and there are people alive today who remember when they could not. Women fought for and won their right to vote in the War of Roses - members of Congress and supporters of suffrage wore yellow roses to show their support, and the opposition wore red roses to show theirs. I would like to take a note from those brave women's hands.
A group of friends any myself have purchased yellow rose rings:
link to picture of rose ring
Which we will wear on our "wedding" fingers in protest of the passing of Proposition 8. It is my way of saying that until EVERYONE can get married - I will not. The religious right won this battle by fooling people into thinking that allowing people to marry would somehow ruin the sanctity of marriage (as if divorce doesn't - don't get me started) - but the sanctity of marriage only continues if we, the people, continue to acknowledge it. I have married friends who have taken black electrical tape, and are taping over their wedding bands to acknowledge the black hole this proposition had turned marriage into. Please join us!
It doesn't matter if you live in California, if you are old enough to vote, or even if you voted Yes and have since changed your mind. This is not about being gay - this is about allowing people to love one another. We have just seen what great things a grass roots movement can do - it can get a inspirational and hope-filled black man elected President - don't let that be our ending point.
As President-elect Obama said in his acceptance speech, "This victory alone is not the change we seek. It is only the chance for us to make that change. And that cannot happen if we go back to the way things were." Let us continue this fight. Together.
"The young women of today - free to study, to speak, to write, to choose their occupation - should remember that every inch of this freedom was bought for them at a great price... the debt that each generation owes to the past, it must pay to the future." ~Abigail Scott Dunaway

Exceptionally well said Meagan! Just as the U.S. Supreme Court tossed out laws banning laws against inter-racial marriage as unconstitutional, the court will rule laws banning same-sex marriages as unconstitutional. In the not too distant future, more and more Gays and Lesbians will be getting married and nobody will think anything of it.
Meagan, What I really would like to see is to simply have civil unions for people be they Gay/Lesbian or heterosexual, who go to the county clerk or the court to tie the knot. Marriage would simply be a religious thing. If a couple wishes to go that route, they simply find a member of the clergy to marry them. As far as the legality goes, it would be all the same.
Walter
i think the idea of civil unions is perfect - because i am not religious, nor do i agree with a lot of the history behind marriage practices - like the giving away of the bride or the idea of "man and wife" - i think a civil union would make many of us who are uncomfortable with marriage more comfortable with the idea
Of course even as it is now, people don't have to do this business of "giving away the bride" or "man and wife." In any case, I'm for calling it civil unions unless the couple chooses to have a religious wedding. Under what I call for, which has been called for by other people too, those who have already had their relationships declared as marriages but did not have religious ceremonies would not be affected. I am also not religious.
I agree that love is what makes the world go round. Without love for your fellow man, where would we be? Not living in a free country for sure. As for equal rights, everyone should have them. Not depending on thier race color or creed. Not depending on their abilities or disabilities. Not depending on who they love. If we are not allowed to show our love then we are not going to survive as I have for my hole life. I live because others care and love me. We need to encourage love where it grows. Thanks for commenting on this issue that is so very important to many
Nobody has denied gays the right to marry.
Just as I cannot enter into a union with 2 women and say it is the "same" as a "marriage" with one woman, gays are not allowed to enter into unions with someone of the same sex and call it marriage.
It is nature that has denied them the right to marry.
Sometimes nature ain't fair.
If one man wants to marry one woman, we call that marriage. Anything else, let's call it something else.
Time to give this a rest.
anonymous,
we are all allowed our own opinions. what we are not allowed is the right to pass our opinions off as laws to ban other people from participating in society. you can believe anything you want to about marriage - and no one is asking you to participate in a gay or lesbian marriage. but defining your religious beliefs as "nature" and then denying people a basic human right based on your definition is not the American way.
Thanks for posting this MD. I would have missed it without you!