Forgive my tardiness on this week's Report Cards, as personal matters got in the way of me getting to a blog I don't get paid to write. Still, I'm left with some different perspectives on both the Chico State basketball teams after this weekend.
Normally, I'd split these bad boys up, but I'm feeling wordy and I think it's about time I had a massive entry. Besides, I just traded off covering a Division VI high school game for some time in the office, and you'd better believe I'll make the most of it.
Let's start with the men's weekend, for alphabetical purposes.
Friday
It's hard to overstate just how crushing the defeat to Cal Poly Pomona was, because for all intents and purposes, the Wildcats had that game won. That was the second straight such defeat, dating back to last week's loss to San Francisco State. But, like in that game, I still think the Wildcats were better than the team that beat them. I usually don't buy into the whole "the better team lost" thing, but in this case, it's hard not to. They show so much potential and ability at times, only to find ways to let other teams in. Yes, they're young, and that's probably the biggest factor here, but the truth is that Chico State should have had a 3-1 homestand over the last two weeks.
More on the Pomona game:
UPS
For once, a steady hand. Chico State got its first "complete" game of the season, never really burying itself so deep it couldn't come back. That's a nice sign. The Broncos are definitely no slouches and have their share of players, so for the Wildcats to hang the whole time and, for stretches, outplay Pomona, showed what Chico State really is capable of.
Half-court offense. This might have been the Wildcats' best offensive performance of the season in terms of patience for the best shot. Up until the very end, Chico State took exquisite care of the ball, looked active in its half-court sets and truly didn't give away possessions. There were obviously things that could have been done better, but on offense — especially around the perimeter — it was largely Chico State's finest hour of the year.
DOWNS
"Whaa....?" That's what I found myself asking after I saw a 2-point lead turn into a 3-point loss in the span of less than 16 seconds. How did that happen? For one, presence of mind (or lack thereof) was instrumental. Let's start with the Wildcats with a 2-point lead, the ball and two timeouts, and the Broncos with no fouls to give and no other way to stop the clock. On the inbound pass, Darroll Phillips (whose 21 points were huge in the Wildcats even having the lead) stepped out of bounds.
Why doesn't he have instructions to just stand there and hold it for five seconds? He's going to get fouled; there's no question. He shouldn't have moved. Burn the clock, get to the line, sink the FTs. That's the tried-and-true formula for protecting a lead in the last minute. Chico State did none of it.
Then, after Pomona tied it, the Wildcats give them possession right back by a halfcourt charge that saw them try to storm down in five seconds (I'm not sure what kind of shot was expected to come from this strategy). They had two timeouts; it seemed like this was the time to use one. Set up a play, get a shot. Instead, a timeout was used after the turnover, which gave Pomona ample time to — get this — draw up an open shot for Angelo Tsagarakis, the one guy who should have been so deep in Wildcat defenders that he couldn't breathe. Another inexplicable final sequence.
Saturday
Not to say the Wildcats had it coming in their loss to the Coyotes, but Cal State San Bernardino is a tremendous ballclub. I don't know how much I buy into the "hangover" talk from Friday night's letdown; I guess, to some degree, it had an effect, but this is one of the teams Chico State actually does not match up with. The Coyotes are big, athletic and play a defense that's as good as any I've seen.
UPS
Errm.... This was just not a good game for Chico State. The intensity wasn't there, and the same offensive ability wasn't, either. Granted, the Coyotes fly to the ball hellaciously. I haven't seen a team play such active defense in CCAA play, maybe ever. Yeah, they have their scorers, and I'll have to see Humboldt State in person, but right now, Cal State San Bernardino is the top dog in this conference because of its defense. You know how you'll play Madden sometimes and the computer always seems to have a triple team on every pass you throw? That's what it was like watching the Coyotes defend.
DOWNS
Please, get to the rim, someone. It's hard to nitpick in a loss like this, ugly as it was, because the Coyotes have so much going right for them. Still, you know what I'd love to see? Mike Martin face the basket and posterize someone. Or Josh Jackson take a ball off the wing and penetrate and attack the hoop. Or something besides this assortment of fallaway shots and desperation 3s (by the way, Chico State still takes way too many of them). Martin in particular stands out as the one guy who should be taking games over.
The more I see him, the clearer it is that he is this team's best athlete and probably the toughest matchup for any CCAA team to defend. But he doesn't take advantage of it, at least not all the time. Channeling Bill Walton, here: "Throw down, big man, throw down."
God, that hurt a little. But it was necessary.
Now, for some better news. The women moved up two spots in Division II to No. 16 after a weekend sweep of Cal Poly Pomona and Cal State San Bernardino; the game against the Coyotes was one of the most inspired defensive efforts the Wildcats have put on. Twelve points into the second half? Yikes.
But, I'm getting ahead of myself. Let's get back to some chronology.
Friday
Yuck. That was the general consensus of anyone who watched this game, including the Wildcats themselves. No, it wasn't pretty, but Chico State took it fairly handily, still. Lots of turnovers, lots of missed shots and lots of grit.
UPS
Speaking of grit... Amanda Monteith doesn't score a lot, but makes up for it a ton on the defensive end. I find it tough to call a 5-foot-9 banger "scrappy," but that's exactly what she is. She's on the floor all the time and plays with just enough of a chip that I would only be mildly surprised if she pulled a Zidane-esque headbutt. I love the way she plays defense.
Obscure no more. Melissa Richardson shook off the title of "unheralded" by picking up the CCAA Player of the Week award for this weekend's games. If she were ever to write a basketball resumé, she could put down "hits decisive 3s with regularity" down as a bulletpoint, along with "grabs every loose ball."
DOWNS
Yeah, all those turnovers. One of the most perplexing statistics I've ever seen is the Wildcats' record under Molly Goodenbour when they turn the ball over more than their opponent. That mark is 13-0 after this weekend, a goofy anomaly that goes against all that is right and pure. You're not supposed to win if you can't hang on to the ball, right? Well, I wouldn't fall too deeply in love with that figure. The law of averages looms heavily over it, especially on the road. Sooner or later, it could catch up.
Saturday
I won't lie; I was pumped to see Cal State San Bernardino and phenom Vanessa Wilt come to town. It was kind of foregone that Monteith would be tasked with covering her, but would it be enough? The Coyotes came to Chico with a ton of pretense and reputation, and I'm sure I wasn't the only one who thought this might be a battle of CCAA titans.
I won't go as far as saying I was let down — after all, I did see something I hadn't seen before — but it was pretty clear the Coyotes were road-weary.
UPS
45-12?! I usually abstain from exclamation points, especially coupled with question marks, but that was the largest lead for Chico State as late as the second half. I expected a defensive focus, but this was intense. I found myself wondering what the modern school record was for fewest points allowed was (a late Coyotes surge made me toss the knowledge out the window, but still).
Welcome back to the fray, Renee. Post Renee Goldoff's impact and minutes had taken somewhat of a hit since Goodenbour went to a smaller starting five, but she showed how important she can be Saturday. Since the preseason schedule, this was as aggressive as I've seen her play offensively, and with all the scoring guard-types on this team, it's easy to forget just how good Goldoff's post moves are. The Wildcats are markedly better when she's playing to her potential.
Edwards' emergence. Cory Edwards' name has been popping up in almost every Goodenbour postgame interview over the last four games, and with good reason. A deep bench fixture last year, Edwards is now a top option in the post and has shown a pretty nice shooting touch from range, too. Where she really stands out, I think, is her ability to get from the high post to the blocks and move a defense with her, and she passes very well. Her rebounding ability also makes her invaluable, especially in a reserve role.
DOWNS
Second-half swoon. It may have been because the Wildcats' subs got in or that the Coyotes' shots started falling, but a sizable second-half run got Cal State San Bernardino to within respectability. Is that really that big of a down? I don't think so, but what I found to be in poor taste was that the Coyotes were fouling — sometimes borderline flagrantly — to stop the clock. When a meaningless buzzer-beating 3 went down for them, they emptied the benches and celebrated on the winners' home floor, the collegiate basketball equivalent of raising a large, stiff middle finger to the hosts.
Bush league.