« US Housing Crash Continues | Main | So, You Think You Want Universal Healthcare? »

November 26, 2006

School of the Americas - The Truth

Nick Freitas, who writes us about a few peacenik ladies from Chico who have totally mispresented the truth and refuse to accept the obvious facts.

It is our pleasure to present to you, Nick's views on this story that was carried in the E-R and in letters to the editor by some of Chico's crazy liberals:

AP2.jpg School of the Americas. . . . . Let me try and explain something to the left about the former "School of Americas". We offer security assistance to friendly governments. We do this so we don't have to send our own soldiers down there to do it for them.

Now we could just send money down there, but then it would probably just get siphoned off to other things, so that wouldn't be good. Or we could send our own soldiers down there to train them, but then that would be more expensive, and require far more instructors. So, for the sake of expense, accountability, etc. we created a school

in the US where all foreign soldiers who attend said school start off their training with extensive humans rights classes. In addition to the human rights classes we can ensure that none of the money we are spending to support our allies goes to things like torture training, or wmd development. Instead they receive useful training in hand to hand combatives, small unit tactics, mission planning, etc.

The School of Americas makes perfect sense to anyone without an absurd far left political agenda.

Lee Rials, public affairs officer for the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation, as the School of the Americas is now called, sent the E-R an e-mail defending his institution.

"I find it amazing that the truth about the School of the Americas and the institute is about 180 degrees from the beliefs these people (the demonstrators) have," he wrote.

"They accept the assertions of this political movement without questioning or looking at the facts that are available to them. The most stark refutation of their beliefs is that not one single example of anyone using what he learned at the school to commit crimes exists - not one.

"The indisputable fact that some who did attend at some time did later commit crimes is irrelevant because no one has shown any cause-effect relationship."

I truly enjoy the analysis difference here. You see the SoA rep says (accurately I might add) that there is no evidence of someone committing crimes based off what they had learned at the School of Americas.
Now there is a large Catholic contingent which usually shows up at these demonstrations because a while back some nuns were killed in Central America by individuals some of whom had attended the school. So why is their former attendance irrelevant as Mr. Rial suggests? Well, its simple, the School of Americas doesn't have a "How to kill a Catholic nun" class. At the risk of sounding obtuse; I can only assume that since Nuns are peaceful and generally unarmed, military training isn't required to kill one. All that is required is a desire to go to hell and avoid the long lines.

Now lets take a look into the liberal argument.

Protester: "Webster said she didn't put any stock in Rials' remarks. She said, "if 1 percent of the graduates of any school were committing serious crimes, it would make sense to look into what was being taught at that school."

First of all, were any of these protesters calling for a "...look into what was being taught at the school." I don't think so, they were screaming, shouting, and breaking the law, all in the name of closing the school down.

Secondly, there have been quite a few real live terrorists who have received training in the US at institutions such as Yale. And as far as I know, Yale doesn't require classes on human rights for its students, but I don't see these same people getting on a bus to go there. The reason is simple. Many of the protesters you see showing up at these demonstrations are more left wing, anti-military than anything else.

Look, if you want to believe that the US is taking the time and effort to ship military students from all over the western hemisphere for the purpose of teaching them how to torture and murder, then my guess is, nothing is going to convince you otherwise. But, it simply isn't true. Military education is just that, a form of education. What an individual chooses to do with it is their decision. Bringing them to the US to train them gives us far more oversight on what is going on.

These same liberals are the ones who want us to step up foreign aid to the third world, which is coincidently some of the least accountable funding you can provide, yet they turn their noses up at the SoA.

The math isnt that hard to compute. These protesters don't like the military. If they were truly concerned with people recieving training here, which they used for evil in their homeland, then there are far more non-military, non-government, highly liberal institutions which they should "...look into what was being taught at the school." Nick Freitas, USA

Posted by Post Scripts at November 26, 2006 12:07 PM

Comments

Great insight and analysis by Nick, unfortunately it isn't likely to be embraced since most of the angst the protesters have is about emotion, not logic.

The only thing I would add is a comment to this:
"if 1 percent of the graduates of any school were committing serious crimes, it would make sense to look into what was being taught at that school."

You could make that same argument for any public, private, or religous school in the USA. What percentage of the general population turns to crime? What percentage of inner city schools have graduates that turn to crime? There must be hundreds if not thousands of schools that need "looked into" around the USA by this bereft left logic.

So why haven't they protested the Oakland School Disctrict, or the Chicago School District, or New York? Again the math is simple, they don't like the military and this yearly protest event has long since lost any sense of reason, its just something they do out of habit. It's probably like the Snowbirds RV migration, probably about meeting old friends more than demanding change.

A friend of mine who's in the landscape business told me a funny story recently about protestors at Alameda Naval Air Station. One of his contracts was to keep up the grounds at the entrance. When his contract was renewed, there was a new provision in the contract that was not negotiable: "The irrigation system for the main gate entrance lawn must be set to keep the ground in a supersaturated condition, and the grass type must be able to withstand that condition.

The Base CO wanted to make sure that anybody trying to "camp" there would be ankle deep in muck.

Additionally, the contract stipulated that a remote control for the irrigation system was to be installed in the gate guard office. This was so the CO could call down to the gate at anytime he chose and tell the guard "I noticed on my way in today the grass is looking a little dry, give it an hour on the sprinklers".

Yeah that should do it. ;)

Posted by: Anthony Watts at November 26, 2006 05:28 PM

Re: School of Americas

Too many emotional citizens would rather take the word of these meddling old women than to trust our own honorable, professional soldiers and trainers.

It's sad, very sad. Every day that passes I think we are losing more and more of country to the kooks.

Posted by: Madhatter at November 27, 2006 09:56 AM

A friend of mine who's in the landscape business told me a funny story...the CO could call down to the gate at anytime he chose and tell the guard "I noticed on my way in today the grass is looking a little dry, give it an hour on the sprinklers".

American ingenuity laced with humor in the military mind...or is it just a man thing? Whatever it is, I love it!

Posted by: Tina at November 29, 2006 07:50 PM

I am sick of these SOA protestors coming into my home town and stiring up trouble. Go back to your own town or where ever you live. I support our Troops and I support the SOA. And if you don't like it then oh well get over it. But stay out of our town and get a damn life.

Posted by: Teresa at December 22, 2007 02:29 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)