Supporting Our Troops
If you ever get the chance to enjoy Gilbert & Sullivan’s classic operetta, The Pirates of Penzance, you should take it. There is a part in the second act, when the heroine, Mabel, is encouraging the police to go and meet the pirates in battle. She sings to a martial tune:
Go, ye heroes, go to glory.
Though ye die in combat gory,
Ye shall live in song and story
Go to immortality!
Go to death and go to slaughter;
Die, and every Cornish daughter
With her tears your grave shall water,
Go, ye heroes, go and die!
It’s hilarious.
William S. Gilbert was a brilliant satirist. Though written in the nineteenth century, his point is still clear: “Supporting” the troops isn’t too good for the troops!
Yet we’re told that “You can’t be for our troops if you’re against the war.”
In this space, I’ve received comments from individuals who have little sympathy for the dead and their families. “They volunteered,” I’ve been told.
“Gee son, your daddy is dead. That’s OK, because he died fighting for . . . . . uh . . . .oh yeah, WMDs . . no wait, that’s not it . . . . to remove a really bad man from power. . . . no, that’s not it either. . . . . . umm, look, your dad died fighting for his country.”
“But my daddy was a mechanic, not a soldier” The little boy protests through anguished sobs.
“Well son, when your dad joined the National Guard fifteen years ago, so he could afford the payments on that nice house you live in, he knew the risks. Tell your mom not to blame the president, she should blame your daddy for volunteering.”
The bottom line is this:
You can support this war or you can support the troops.
You cannot do both.
On the other hand, I suppose you can be a coward, support this war, and just pretend to support the troops, while expecting other people’s children to fight this war for you—like our president.
