« Supporting Our Troops | Main | Gun Control? Never! »

A Better Idea On Taxes (Spread It Around)

It seemed appropriate to present my plan to fix the tax code this week.
A plan that would make taxes fairer. A plan that would make taxes voluntary. A plan that would actually raise more money for the Treasury. A plan that would save the billions of dollars Americans spend trying to figure out their taxes. A plan that could rapidly lower the National Debt—which just happens to be the largest threat to our security. A plan that would stimulate the economy. A great plan. Unfortunately, it is a plan that will never happen if the people do not lead.
Some background: If you go to
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2006/tables/06s0464.xlw
(you will need Excel to view it), you will find that the government received 1.1202 trillion dollars from income taxes, personal and corporate, in 2005. This is the last year for which numbers are available.
I did some checking around and I found that the value of all the assets traded in all of the American stock and commodity markets totals over twenty trillion dollars annually.
Let’s do some math: 1.1202/20=.05601.
If our government taxed the purchase of stocks and commodities at a mere 5.6%, they would raise the same amount of money they do now.
If the tax rate was 10%, the extra 879.8 billion dollars every year could retire the National Debt in a little over ten years.
A simple plan.
As it is now of course, most people pay more than 10% of their income in income tax. Many corporations end up paying far less than that amount, and would naturally be opposed to any changes in what they themselves have wrought with their corruption of Congress.
The plan is voluntary in that no one would be forced to buy stocks or commodities. Of course, most people would probably want to invest their money, having more of it.
The corporate media will say that a tax on investment reduces investment.
Does a tax on working reduce working?
The corporate media will say that this plan is inflationary.
Don't believe it. (What causes inflation and what it really is are the subjects of another essay.)
Gains on stocks and commodities are currently taxed at either regular income or long-term capital gains rates—which are both higher than 10%.
As more people invested in America, the revenues to the Treasury would increase. The revenues to the businesses traded would increase, stimulating the economy—honestly, not like it is now with manipulation. The capital that would spread among “We the people,” would raise the standard of living for all Americans—not just the few. The concentration of wealth would ease.
Besides corporate America—and the multinationals traded in America—there would be strong opposition to this idea by other powerful interests.
The instruments of the National Debt are held mostly by banks and foreign governments (you would be amazed if you knew how much we are in debt to China!). Some of these instruments pay interest of close to 15%, but if we were to use a modest figure of 5% interest overall, we are paying just about 445 billion dollars a year in interest. The folks on the receiving end of that 445 billion are going to oppose anything that would threaten their golden goose.
General Motors bought a car company a few years ago for 67 billion. With this plan, they would pay 6.7 billion in taxes—far more than they have ever paid, but closer to their fair share. They would be against it.
Finally, let’s not forget the people who make close to twenty billion a year figuring out taxes. I’m sure they would oppose this idea too.
The odds are against us—unless we speak up.
If you don’t think this is a good idea, I want you to do something. Your personal share of the interest on the National Debt comes to just over four dollars a day. Take four dollars for every person in you family and flush it down the toilet. Do this every day for a year. What will you have to show for it?
Exactly what we have to show from paying interest on the debt. The debt doesn’t go down one bit. In fact, it’s climbing about 23,000 dollars every second. If we don’t tame the debt—and soon—we have damned our future as a country. When the creditors come calling, and we don’t have the money to pay them, they own us.
If you think this is a good idea; a fair idea, forward it to everyone you know. Ask them to forward it to someone else.
Maybe if enough people heard about it, something good will come of it.

Comments

What do you think of the idea of a flat tax? The proposal I had heard about suggested that everyone pay a fair rate of 10%. People making under $40,000 annually would not have to pay, and everyone else would pay on the amount over $40,000 that they made. So someone making $60,000 annually would pay 10% of $20,000, which is $2,000, and someone making $100,000 would pay $6,000 in taxes.
This process would be fair and simple. Every individual would pay the same percentage regardless of income or how they earned it. Those who are scraping by on $30,000 a year wouldn't have to pay at all and the penalty of improving their life by making more than $40,000 wouldn't be that horrible either.
I would guess that H&R Block and lots of tax attorneys would be against this, but certainly the people could support it as well.
Now that I've made my own suggestion, do I still have to use dollar bills for toilet paper as you suggested? I prefer Charmin :)

===============================================
I always look forward to your responses, sir. Thank you.
I am not fond of a flat tax, as none of the proposals I've seen adequately address the issue of corporate taxes.
Further, it does not address the issue of what "income" is! If a corporation "pays" the CEO a dollar a year, but gives "bonuses" of, oh, say, 165 million dollars, what then?
Additionally, a flat tax would be confiscatory. In my opinion, that would give people an incentive to cheat--say, getting all you wages over 40K under the table, or the aforementioned corporate stunt.
Not only would my voluntary plan remove the incentives for scofflaws, but Uncle Sam already monitors every transaction. The software is already there to keep track of revenues.
Unbeknownst to most, the National Debt is the single biggest threat facing this country. History shows what happens to large debtor nations--post WWI Germany comes to mind.
Have you noticed the dollar's value relative to the Euro? Record territory!
The corporate media are out there like Kevin Bacon in Animal House, shouting "All is well, all is well!" Don't you believe it.
If we don't take care of the debt--and soon, you better hang on to those dollar bills--they'll be cheaper to use than Charmin. That's OK, they soften up after you wash them a few times.
Please know that I think your idea is the best I've heard; way better than that 17% sales tax idea.
However, my plan is better.
Please tell your friends.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)