by Jack Lee
In 2010 Sen. Sam Aanested-R will be termed out of office in the 4th Senatorial District and you will be asked to vote for his replacement. You might think that is a long way off, but in politics that date is just around the corner and they are busy figuring out ways to win your vote. So before all these phony baloney mailers start coming out I would like to share some thoughts about the current candidates.
Right now we know of only two contenders for the Senate in the 4th District, Doug LaMalfa (farmer from Richvale) and Rick Keene (lawyer from Chico), both are conservative republicans and both are well liked and both have served full terms in the Assembly. Both candidates have a good voting record, although LaMalfa’s record is rated slightly better according to several conservative groups that track such things, but they are still pretty close.
The 4th Senate District covers a predominantly rural farming region that includes Butte, Colusa, Del Norte, Glenn, Nevada (partly), Placer (partly), Shasta, Siskiyou, Sutter, Tehema, Trinity and Yuba Counties. As in past elections, Butte County is the key to winning with the highest number of republican voters and you voters in Chico really hold the most sway in this county. So ground zero for this Senate race is really right here in Chico!
FACTOID: In his last year in office Keene raised $$916,356.00. His ending cash in his campaign contributions was $1,023,641.82
FACTOID: In his last in office LaMalfa raised $216,769.15 for his last year in office. His ending cash in his campaign contributions was $530,877.11
Now this from Maplight: These are the top ten money givers to Doug LaMalfa and Rick Keene.
(Lamalfa) Farmers in general gave Doug LaMalfa $61,700, Lumber and wood products & lumber yards $33,375, Police & fire fighters unions and associations $26,230, Pacific Gas & electric utilities $20,500, Insurance companies, general $20,350, Native American tribes & governing units (gambling) $20,200, Real estate, $16,825, Tele-communications $14,500, Auto dealers, new & used $13,625, Tobacco comapnies & tobacco product sales $13,400
(Keene) Rick Keene took $36,600 from Insurance companies, Real estate gave him $31,750 35%, Police & fire fighters unions and associations $31,399, Native American tribes & governing units (gambling) $28,416, Lumber and wood products & lumber yards $23,950, Builders associations $22,441, Gas & electric utilities $19,400, Physicians $18,350, Pharmaceutical manufacturing $18,200, Attorneys & law firms $16,425,
So, to summarize the top 3 givers, Keene took a lot of money from Insurance companies, police and fire unions, and gaming, and LaMalfa took a lot of money from farmers, lumber and police and fire unions.
My theory is that whoever raises the most money probably has made the most backroom deals and is the most crooked. Simple logic I know, but past performance has told me I’m right! Lawyer Keene has taken in almost twice as much as Farmer LaMalfa, so for whatever thats worth…there you go.
Next, as I said earlier Doug LaMalfa has a slightly better voting record, but Keene is better at raising money from special interest groups and that makes him the odds on favorite. He who spends the most to buy your vote usually wins. That’s a statistical fact and I wish you would prove me wrong on this, but maybe this subject of money and politics is best left for another article….we’ll see.
Unions, insurance companies and the medical industry seem to have an attraction to Keene. This doesn’t mean that Keene is beholding to them or that he will write favorable legislation when the time comes, it just means that he [probably] would. Is there anyone out here who still doesn’t understand that one? LaMalfa’s contributions seem less focused and tend to come from small donors, I like that better.
We should also know that Lawyer Keene handpicked his own successor several years before he was termed out of office and then did everything in his power to get his man elected and he was. His Assembly replacement was Dan Logue and not surprisingly he is strongly supporting Rick Keene for his election. Keene’s former Chief of Staff is now Logue’s and he is also Keene’s current campaign advisor. His advisor has been busy too, he has helped start up a number of California Republican Assembly units aka CRA units within his Senate district and this is intended to pay off when it comes time to get the CRA endorsement. Typically such units exist only long enough to do the endorsement and then they fold up, kinda sleezey, huh? Another Keene employee has been running the local Butte County Central Committee and is most recently chairing one of these newly formed CRA units. Want to bet on who the so-called independent Central Committees will wind up endorsing? Yeah, this stuff gets really messy, all these little power plays and just to make it look like one candidate has more endorsements than the other candidate. This part really sucks about elections. The other part that sucks is all that legal bribe money they take in, but that’s our system.
The Keene Machine is attached to the Aanested campaign and that will be a huge help in exchanging endorsements for each other. All this Machiavellian tactics and infiltrating political organizations for no other purpose than to get an endorsement at the right time to sway the election for their boss.
Farmer Doug LaMalfa is running more of an ordinary campaign and this means he has his work cut out for him if he is going to stay up with Lawyer Rick Keene’s big political machine. However, if there is an upside here, it’s that this battle for the Senate is won by either candidate we will have pretty good representation. I may not like how Keene runs for office (too clever – too many deals made) but I don’t dislike his voting record.
On a more personal note I truly do like both candidates and I know them to be good family men, so for me it really only breaks down to how ethical I think they are running their campaigns, other than that I see them as pretty equal.
I’ll probably vote for the farmer (LaMalfa) because he’s the clear underdog. He’s more like us regular everyday folks and he did reject that fat pay raise awhile back that the Assembly voted for themselves, remember that one? It came just as California’s government was going broke. Lawyer Keene has no such objections, he gladly took the raise. I know, that was small stuff, but it all points to character in my book. But, you folks have draw your own moral line in the sand and decide for yourself. I’m just saying at this early point this is how it looks to me.
I just hope both candidates will run on the issues and spare us all the fake promises and BS we are so used to hearing once the campaigns start ramping up.
Question: How many Senate Districts does California have? 4, 40 or 80? Answer is on page two.
Continue reading “California Senate Race (Dist 4) 2010” »